Esta página ha sido redactada, editada, revisada y aprobada por Rubén Davidoff siguiendo nuestro exhaustivo directrices editoriales Ruben Davidoff, El socio fundador cuenta con más de 30 años de experiencia legal como abogado especializado en lesiones personales en Nueva York.
Índice
Key Takeaways
- Labor Law § 240(1) protects qualifying workers against specific elevation-related hazards, including falls and inadequately secured loads.
- Property owners and contractors may face strict liability when a statutory violation causes an injury.
- Ordinary comparative negligence generally does not defeat a valid § 240(1) claim, but the worker's conduct can sometimes be the sole cause.
- Eligible workers may pursue a third-party lawsuit while receiving workers' compensation, subject to applicable rules.
New York Labor Law § 240, commonly called the Scaffold Law, protects workers from certain gravity-related hazards during construction, demolition, repairs, and other covered activities. It requires property owners, contractors, and their agents to provide appropriate safety devices, including scaffolds, ladders, and hoists.
When inadequate protection causes a qualifying injury, these parties may face strict liability even without directly supervising the work.
However, not every fall or construction accident qualifies. This article explains who the Scaffold Law protects, when it applies, and how injured workers can pursue compensation.
What Is New York Labor Law 240?
New York Labor Law § 240(1) requires owners, contractors, and their agents to provide proper safety devices for workers performing specified activities involving buildings or structures.
The statute identifies equipment such as scaffolds, ladders, hoists, slings, pulleys, ropes, and braces.
These devices must provide adequate protection against hazards arising from elevation differences. The law is designed to place responsibility for these protections on parties positioned to provide them.
Importantly, the Scaffold Law does not require every accident to involve an actual scaffold. Ladder failures, unsecured loads, and other qualifying gravity-related incidents may also fall within its scope.
What Types of Accidents Does the Scaffold Law Cover?
Labor Law § 240(1) generally addresses injuries directly caused by inadequate protection against a significant elevation-related hazard.
Falls From Scaffolds, Ladders, and Elevated Platforms
A worker may have a claim when an improperly secured ladder shifts, a scaffold collapses, or an inadequate elevated platform causes a fall. The issue is whether an appropriate safety device was missing or inadequate and whether that failure caused the injury.
Simply falling from a ladder does not automatically establish liability.
Falling Objects and Unsecured Materials
Workers may also be injured by falling construction materials, equipment, or loads that should have been secured.
For example, a heavy component falling during a lifting operation may involve an inadequate hoist or securing device. In Wilinski v. 334 East 92nd Housing Development Fund Corp., the Court of Appeals examined gravity-related hazards involving unsecured pipes.
Injuries Without a Falling Worker
A worker does not always have to fall or be struck by an object for § 240(1) to apply.
En Runner v. New York Stock Exchange, Inc., the Court of Appeals considered an injury involving a descending heavy load and an inadequate pulley arrangement. The central issue was whether the injury directly resulted from insufficient protection against a physically significant elevation differential.
Is There a Minimum Height for a Scaffold Law Claim?
No. Labor Law § 240(1) has no universal minimum height requirement.
Courts examine whether inadequate safety protection caused an injury involving a physically significant elevation difference. For falling objects or descending loads, the object’s weight and potential force also matter, even over a short distance. A short fall does not automatically qualify or rule out a claim.
Who Is Protected Under Labor Law 240?
The Scaffold Law protects people employed in qualifying work involving the erection, demolition, repairing, altering, painting, cleaning, or pointing of buildings or structures. Covered workers may include construction laborers, electricians, painters, and others performing qualifying tasks. Coverage depends on the activity, not simply the worker's job title.
Does the Law Cover Maintenance Workers?
Not necessarily. Routine maintenance is generally excluded when the work does not constitute a covered statutory activity.
En Soto v. J. Crew Inc., the Court of Appeals held that routine commercial dusting was not protected cleaning under § 240(1). Commercial window washing and certain specialized cleaning projects may qualify, depending on their circumstances.
Does the Law Protect Independent Contractors?
Potentially. Classification as an independent contractor does not automatically exclude someone from protection. Courts examine whether the individual performed qualifying work and whether the other statutory requirements are satisfied.
Who Can Be Held Liable Under New York's Scaffold Law?
Property owners, general contractors, and qualifying statutory agents may be liable when a violation of Labor Law § 240(1) causes an injury.
The law imposes a nondelegable duty on covered parties. A property owner therefore cannot necessarily avoid liability by arguing that another contractor controlled the worksite. However, not every subcontractor or business at a project automatically qualifies as a statutory agent.
Courts examine the party's authority and responsibilities concerning the relevant work.
Are Homeowners Exempt From the Scaffold Law?
Owners of one- and two-family dwellings generally qualify for a statutory exemption when they contract for construction work but do not direct or control it.
The exemption depends on the property's use and the owner's involvement. A homeowner who exercises relevant direction or control may not receive the exemption merely because the property contains one or two residences.
Does Labor Law 240 Impose Strict Liability?
Yes, but strict liability under § 240(1) does not mean that every injured construction worker automatically wins a lawsuit.
The worker must establish a qualifying activity, a covered elevation-related hazard, an inadequate or missing safety device, and a causal connection between the violation and the injury.
When those requirements are established, the defendant generally cannot rely on the worker's ordinary comparative negligence to reduce statutory liability. The Court of Appeals explained these principles in Blake v. Neighborhood Housing Services of New York City.
What Is the Sole Proximate Cause Defense?
A defendant may avoid § 240(1) liability when the worker's own conduct was the sole proximate cause of the accident.
For example, a dispute may arise when an adequate safety device was readily available, the worker knew it was expected to be used, and the worker chose not to use it without a sufficient reason.
Merely alleging that the worker was careless is not enough.
What Is the Difference Between Labor Laws 200, 240, and 241?
These statutes address different construction safety obligations.
| Law | Main purpose |
| Labor Law § 200 | General workplace safety duties and negligence principles |
| Labor Law § 240(1) | Specific gravity-related risks requiring appropriate elevation safety devices |
| Labor Law § 241(6) | Construction, excavation, and demolition safety requirements supported by applicable Industrial Code rules |
For example, a fall from an inadequately secured scaffold may implicate § 240(1), while a hazardous worksite condition may present questions under § 200 or § 241(6). A single accident may support more than one legal theory, but each has different requirements.
Can I Sue Under the Scaffold Law While Receiving Workers' Compensation?
Yes, eligible injured workers may receive workers' compensation benefits while pursuing a separate claim against a legally responsible third party.
Workers' compensation generally provides qualifying medical and wage-loss benefits without requiring proof of employer negligence. A Scaffold Law lawsuit, by contrast, may involve a property owner, contractor, or another qualifying defendant.
Bajo Workers' Compensation Law § 29, certain third-party recoveries are subject to reimbursement, consent, and other requirements. The existence of a Scaffold Law claim does not automatically permit an employee to sue a covered employer directly.
What Compensation Is Available in a Scaffold Law Lawsuit?
A successful Scaffold Law claim may provide compensation for medical expenses, lost earnings, pain and suffering, and other legally recoverable damages.
Daños económicos
Economic losses may include hospitalization, surgery, rehabilitation, lost wages, reduced earning capacity, and reasonably anticipated future care. Serious spinal cord injuries or traumatic brain injuries may require long-term treatment and assistance.
Daños no económicos
An injured worker may also pursue qualifying compensation for pain, suffering, disability, disfigurement, and loss of enjoyment of life. There is no automatic settlement amount simply because Labor Law § 240 applies. Compensation depends on the evidence, injury severity, medical prognosis, and other circumstances.
What Evidence Helps Prove a Scaffold Law Violation?
An investigation should establish what work was being performed, which safety devices were available, and why the accident happened.
Important evidence may include:
- Photographs of ladders, scaffolds, hoists, and the accident scene
- Incident reports and witness statements
- Equipment inspection and maintenance records
- Construction contracts and project documentation
- Safety instructions and relevant communications
- Medical records and employment documentation
Photographs and physical evidence are particularly valuable when equipment is removed or repaired after an accident. An attorney may also consult appropriate construction safety or engineering specialists.
What Should You Do After a Scaffold or Ladder Accident?
Seek medical treatment, report the accident, and preserve evidence when it is safe to do so.
- Obtain appropriate emergency medical care.
- Report the injury to your employer or supervisor.
- Photograph the equipment and surrounding conditions when safe.
- Identify coworkers or witnesses who observed the incident.
- Preserve relevant messages, reports, and available photographs.
- Keep medical records and documentation of missed work.
- Consult an attorney about workers' compensation and potential third-party claims.
Do not return to an unsafe area solely to collect evidence.
How Long Do You Have to File a Scaffold Law Lawsuit in New York?
Most personal injury lawsuits involving Labor Law § 240(1) must be commenced within three years, generally under CPLR § 214(5). However, claims involving public entities may have shorter or different procedural deadlines.
For covered municipal claims, General Municipal Law § 50-e generally requires a notice of claim within 90 days. Claims involving public authorities or the State of New York may follow different statutory procedures.
Workers' compensation notices and benefit claims also involve separate requirements. Because important evidence can disappear quickly, early legal review is valuable even when the ordinary lawsuit deadline has not approached.
Frequently Asked Questions About New York's Scaffold Law
No. The accident must involve covered work and a qualifying elevation-related hazard, and an applicable statutory violation must have caused the injury.
Not necessarily. A claim may involve an absent, improperly placed, unsecured, or otherwise inadequate safety device rather than a manufacturing defect.
Potentially. Ordinary comparative negligence generally does not defeat a valid § 240(1) claim, but evidence that the worker's conduct was the sole proximate cause may affect liability.
Sometimes. The question is whether the object's fall involved a gravity-related risk requiring appropriate statutory protection, not simply whether something fell.
Speak With Davidoff Law About a Construction Accident
New York's Scaffold Law provides important protections, but determining whether an accident qualifies requires careful investigation of the work, safety equipment, and responsible parties.
At Davidoff Law, we help injured individuals throughout New York City understand potential construction accident claims and available compensation.
If you were injured by a scaffold failure, ladder accident, or falling object, call 718-268-8800 for a free consultation about your legal options.
Abogados especializados en lesiones personales de Davidoff Law
- 75-60 188th Street, Fresh Meadows, NY 11366
- (718) 900-0000
Abogados especializados en lesiones personales Davidoff Law - Ciudad de Nueva York
- 60 E 42nd Street, Suite 1720, Nueva York, NY 10165
- (212) 900-0000
SOLO CON CITA PREVIA
Abogados de lesiones personales Davidoff Law - Bronx
- 2322 Arthur Ave, 207, Bronx, NY 10458
- (516) 830-0956
Abogado especializado en lesiones personales en Queens Rubén Davidoff
- 108-18 Queens Blvd., Suite 404, Queens, NY 11375
- (718) 268-8800

Rubén Davidoff, fundador de Davidoff Law, estableció su despacho en 2012 tras mudarse a Queens en 1988 y comenzar su carrera jurídica en 1997. Admitido en el estado de Nueva York y en el Tribunal de Distrito de los Estados Unidos para el Distrito Este de Nueva York, cuenta con una amplia experiencia en lesiones personales, habiendo llevado diversos casos como accidentes aéreos, accidentes automovilísticos y casos de resbalones, tropiezos y caídas. El Sr. Davidoff ofrece una atención personalizada y ha recuperado millones para sus clientes a través de acuerdos o veredictos, aprovechando sus décadas de experiencia.

