Our 108-18 Queens Blvd office is moving to 75-60 188th St, Flushing NY 11366
We've moved! Now located at 75-60 188th Street Fresh Meadows, NY 11366

Independent Medical Examinations

This page was written, edited, reviewed & approved by Ruben Davidoff following our comprehensive editorial guidelines Ruben Davidoff, the Founding Partner, has 30+ years of legal experience as a New York personal injury attorney.

An independent medical examination (IME) is an exam by a doctor the insurance company or defense chooses to evaluate your injuries. The doctor does not treat you, but the report often shapes how the insurer values your claim. If a notice just arrived, feeling anxious or even insulted is normal, especially while your own doctors are still treating you.

New York applies different rules depending on whether the independent medical examination is part of a no-fault claim, a personal injury lawsuit, or a workers' compensation case. At Davidoff Law, we prepare clients across New York City for each type of IME and respond to the reports that follow.

Call 718-268-8800 before your exam date so we can review the notice with you.

How Davidoff Law Helps Before and After an Independent Medical Examination

An IME notice signals that the other side is building its medical case. Our role is to check that the exam follows the rules and that your side of the medical story is documented. 

Depending on your case, our attorneys can:

  • Review the notice for the date, location, examining doctor, and scope
  • Raise objections to an improper time, place, or doctor within the deadlines that apply
  • Arrange for a representative to attend when the rules allow it
  • Prepare you for the questions and physical tests the doctor may use
  • Obtain the IME report and compare it with your treatment records
  • Work with your treating doctors when a rebuttal report may help

Our offices in Fresh Meadows, Manhattan, and the Bronx serve injured people throughout the five boroughs, and our team speaks Spanish. One client review credits a member of our team with helping on no-fault insurance, the part of a car accident claim where IME scheduling often begins.

What Is an Independent Medical Examination in New York?

An independent medical examination is a medical evaluation requested by the insurer, employer's carrier, or defendant you are seeking benefits or compensation from. The exam is for evaluation, not treatment. The doctor usually reviews your records, asks questions, and performs a physical exam focused on the following issues:

  • Your diagnosis and how the doctor describes your injuries
  • Whether the accident or work incident caused your symptoms
  • Whether more treatment, therapy, or surgery is medically necessary
  • Whether your condition is permanent or still improving
  • Whether you can return to work, and with what restrictions

When Can You Be Required to Attend an IME in New York?

Whether you must attend, and which protections apply, depends on the type of claim. In New York, IMEs usually arise in the following settings:

  • No-fault insurance claims after a car accident
  • Personal injury lawsuits
  • Workers' compensation claims

No-Fault IMEs After a Car Accident

Your no-fault policy requires you to attend exams by doctors the insurer selects or approves, as often as it may reasonably require. In New York no-fault insurance claims, missing an IME can put your benefits at risk.

The insurer has rules to follow, too. According to Department of Financial Services guidance on no-fault IMEs, it must:

  • Schedule an IME requested to verify your claim within 30 calendar days of receiving the required verification forms
  • Hold the exam at a reasonably convenient time and place, in a properly equipped facility
  • Tell you, when it schedules the exam, that you will be reimbursed for lost earnings and reasonable transportation expenses

If the date or place doesn't work for you, call us before the appointment so we can ask the insurer to reschedule. Keep pay stubs, receipts, and ride records to support your reimbursement request.

Defense Medical Exams in a Personal Injury Lawsuit

After a lawsuit is filed and your physical condition is in dispute, CPLR 3121 allows the defense to require an examination by a designated physician.

In Supreme Court personal injury cases, 22 NYCRR 202.17 generally requires the exam to be scheduled 30 to 60 days after notice is served, unless the parties agree otherwise. You may also need to provide treating-doctor reports and record authorizations before the exam.

Davidoff Law can help prepare the required records, review the exam notice, and address objections to the timing, location, or examining doctor.

Workers' Compensation IMEs

A workers' compensation independent medical examination is governed by Workers' Compensation Law § 137, and the Workers' Compensation Board's IME notice (Form IME-5) lists your rights. You must receive notice at least 7 business days before the exam, and the notice must say whether the examiner intends to record it.

The exam must be held in a safe, accessible location within a reasonable distance of your home, during regular business hours unless you agree otherwise. The examiner cannot be a doctor who already treated or examined you for the condition, or another member of that doctor's preferred provider or managed care group.

If the carrier or employer requested the exam, you have the right to reimbursement for travel to and from it. Bring the notice to your first call with us so we can confirm each requirement was met.

What Are Your Rights During an Independent Medical Examination?

New York's rules and guidelines for an independent medical examination vary by claim type. Depending on your claim, the law may give you protections such as the following:

  • Advance written notice of the exam, including its conditions and scope in a lawsuit
  • Reimbursement for lost earnings and reasonable transportation in a no-fault claim
  • Travel reimbursement in workers' compensation when the carrier or employer requested the exam
  • A copy of the IME report, served within 45 days after a lawsuit exam or sent to you on the same day it is submitted in workers' compensation
  • The ability to object when the time, place, or doctor is improper
  • An exam in a suitable facility that respects your privacy and dignity in a workers' compensation case

Can I Bring Someone With Me to an IME?

In a lawsuit, a New York appellate decision on IME attendance recognized that you can normally have your attorney present. In workers' compensation, the Board's notice lets you bring one or more people of your choosing.

For a no-fault exam, ask us before the appointment. Whoever attends should observe without interfering, which helps avoid disputes over whether the exam was completed.

Can I Record My Independent Medical Examination?

In a lawsuit, you need the court's permission, which the same appellate court said is granted only in special and unusual circumstances. In an appellate case involving a secretly recorded IME, recording without permission was, by itself, enough to bar the video at trial.

Workers' compensation is different: The Board's notice gives you the right to videotape or otherwise record the exam. For a no-fault exam, talk with us before you record.

How to Prepare for Your Independent Medical Examination

Preparation lowers anxiety and helps the report reflect what you actually experience. These steps help most people get ready:

  1. Call your attorney as soon as the notice arrives so any objection to the date, place, or doctor can be raised on time.
  2. Review your treatment history, including the accident date, surgeries, therapy, and major appointments.
  3. Bring a photo ID, the appointment notice, and a current list of medications.
  4. Confirm who will attend with you and whether you need an interpreter.
  5. Save receipts, ride records, and pay information for any travel or lost earnings tied to the exam.
  6. Arrive early, wear comfortable clothing, and expect to be observed from the moment you arrive.
  7. Write down the start and end times, the tests performed, and the questions asked as soon as the exam ends.

Do not bring new imaging or records unless we ask you to. In a lawsuit, records are exchanged under court rules, and handing documents directly to the examiner can create confusion.

What to Say and What Not to Say to an IME Doctor

Honest, consistent answers are your best protection. Keep the following points in mind:

  • Describe your symptoms accurately, including good days and bad days
  • Avoid exaggerating pain or limitations, and avoid downplaying them
  • Mention prior injuries truthfully if the doctor asks about them
  • Skip guessing about diagnoses, dates, or test results
  • Leave fault, settlement, and your conversations with your attorney out of the discussion
  • Tell the doctor right away if a test causes sharp pain

Remember that the IME doctor is not your doctor. Questions about your care belong with your treating physicians.

What Happens During the Exam?

Most IMEs follow a predictable pattern. The doctor typically reviews your records, asks about the accident and your symptoms, and performs physical tests such as range of motion, strength, and reflexes.

Some exams are shorter than a typical office visit. The times you record afterward can matter if the report describes a more detailed exam than the one you received.

What Happens If You Miss or Refuse an IME?

Missing an IME without a valid reason can hurt your claim. The consequences depend on the type of claim:

  • No-fault: The insurer must follow up within 10 calendar days and offer a second chance to attend. Missing twice may breach the policy condition and cost you coverage, although a reasonable excuse can change that.
  • Lawsuit: Raise scheduling problems before the exam date. Delays in the exam and medical exchange can push back when your case reaches trial.
  • Workers' compensation: Contact the person listed on your notice as soon as possible. Your ability to attend does not, by itself, decide whether you are disabled.

If you have a conflict, call us right away so we can help you reschedule through the proper channel.

How an IME Report Can Affect Your New York Injury Claim

An IME report is one doctor's opinion, but insurers and defense lawyers rely on it heavily. It can affect your benefits, your settlement discussions, and the evidence presented at trial. When the report minimizes your injuries, it can also shrink the defense's view of the damages available in New York personal injury cases, such as future medical costs and pain and suffering.

Losing No-Fault Benefits After a Negative IME

After a no-fault IME, the exam date counts as the date the insurer received verification, and the insurer then has 30 days to pay or deny the related claims. If the doctor finds that no further treatment is needed, the earliest a cutoff can take effect is the date the insurer sends the denial.

A denial is not always the final word. We review the report, the timing of the denial, and your treating doctor's records to evaluate your options for challenging it.

Disputing the Serious Injury Threshold

In car accident lawsuits, defense doctors often address whether your injury meets New York's statutory definition of serious injury. Under Insurance Law § 5102(d), as currently published, a serious injury includes any of the following:

  • Death
  • Dismemberment
  • Significant disfigurement
  • A fracture
  • Loss of a fetus
  • Permanent loss of use of a body organ, member, function, or system
  • Permanent consequential limitation of use of a body organ or member
  • Significant limitation of use of a body function or system

The statute was revised in 2026, so older summaries online may list categories that no longer appear in the current text. When an IME doctor says your injury falls short, our approach to serious injury claims focuses on imaging, measured range-of-motion findings, and your treating physicians' opinions.

When the IME Doctor Blames a Pre-Existing Condition

IME reports often attribute pain to arthritis, prior injuries, or age-related wear rather than the accident. A prior condition does not necessarily end the discussion. We compare your records from before and after the accident to show how your symptoms, limitations, and treatment changed.

How to Challenge an Unfavorable IME Report

An unfavorable report can be answered with evidence. Depending on the claim, our response may include the following:

  • Comparing the report with your notes about how long the exam took and which tests were performed
  • Asking your treating physicians for reports that respond to the IME doctor's conclusions
  • Serving medical reports on time, because court rules can bar testimony from doctors whose reports were not exchanged
  • Pointing out conflicts between the report and your imaging, therapy notes, and work restrictions
  • Appealing a Workers' Compensation Board decision that relies on an IME

In some workers' compensation cases where the Board has already directed ongoing payments, an IME report alone cannot suspend or reduce those payments. The Board's rules must be met, and the Board must find that the change is justified.

How Long After an IME Does a New York Case Settle?

There is no set timeline for settlement after an IME. In a lawsuit, the examining doctor's report must be served within 45 days after the exam, and both sides often reassess the case once it arrives. Settlement discussions also depend on your treatment progress, any dispute over fault, and the court's schedule.

Keep the filing deadline in mind while you wait. Under CPLR 214, New York's statute of limitations for most personal injury lawsuits is 3 years.

Contact Our New York City Personal Injury Lawyer Before Your Independent Medical Examination

An independent medical examination can influence your benefits, your settlement discussions, and your trial evidence. Davidoff Law prepares clients across New York City for no-fault, lawsuit, and workers' compensation IMEs and responds when reports misstate their injuries.

Founder and Managing Attorney Ruben Davidoff and our team handle personal injury cases on a contingency fee basis. Call 718-268-8800 any time, day or night, for a free case evaluation before your exam date.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Personal Injury Lawyer

Ruben Davidoff, founder of Davidoff Law, established his practice in 2012 after moving to Queens in 1988 and beginning his legal career in 1997. Admitted in NY State and the US District Court for the Eastern District of NY, he has extensive experience in personal injury, handling various cases like airline crashes, auto accidents, and slip/trip and fall cases. Mr. Davidoff provides personalized attention, recovering millions for clients through settlements or verdicts, leveraging decades of experience.

Schedule Your Free
Consultation

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name*
Required Field*
Consent

Contact Us

If you or a loved one needs the assistance of our personal injury law attorneys, please feel free to contact in the way that is most convenient to you, whether that is calling us at (718) 268-8800 or completing the contact form below. All fields are required.

chevron-down