Our 108-18 Queens Blvd office is moving to 75-60 188th St, Flushing NY 11366
We've moved! Now located at 75-60 188th Street Fresh Meadows, NY 11366

Subrogation

This page was written, edited, reviewed & approved by Ruben Davidoff following our comprehensive editorial guidelines Ruben Davidoff, the Founding Partner, has 30+ years of legal experience as a New York personal injury attorney.

Key Takeaways

  • Subrogation allows an insurer or another payer to pursue certain recovery rights after paying a covered loss.
  • New York General Obligations Law § 5-335 restricts many health insurance reimbursement claims against personal injury settlements.
  • Medicare, Medicaid, workers' compensation, and certain self-funded ERISA plans may have separate recovery rights.
  • A claimed reimbursement amount should be verified before settlement proceeds are distributed.

Subrogation is the legal process that allows an insurance company or another payer to pursue recovery from a party responsible for a loss it covered. In personal injury cases, this may involve an insurer seeking reimbursement for medical expenses or benefits paid after an accident. However, New York law limits many reimbursement claims, and not every insurer can legally recover money from your settlement.

Understanding subrogation matters because a valid reimbursement claim can affect how much compensation you ultimately receive. At Davidoff Law, we help injured New Yorkers evaluate personal injury claims and the insurance issues that may arise during settlement.

What Is Subrogation in Insurance?

Subrogation allows an insurer that has paid a covered loss to exercise certain legal rights against a responsible third party. Rather than requiring the insured person to recover the same expense twice, the insurer may pursue repayment under an applicable contract or law.

For example, imagine a driver causes an accident and another insurer pays $15,000 for resulting expenses. That insurer may attempt to recover the money from the responsible party or the party's insurer.

Whether reimbursement is permitted depends on the coverage, the claim, and governing law.

How Does Subrogation Work in a Personal Injury Claim?

Subrogation may arise when an insurer pays expenses connected to an accident and another party may be legally responsible for those expenses. The process generally involves determining what benefits were paid, identifying a possible right of recovery, and pursuing reimbursement under the applicable law.

For example, a person injured in a car accident might receive medical treatment through an insurance plan before settling a lawsuit against the negligent driver. The insurer might then assert a claim involving those payments.

However, this does not automatically mean the insurer is entitled to reimbursement. New York's anti-subrogation statute may prohibit the claim, while federal law or another statutory exception may preserve it.

What Is the Difference Between Subrogation and a Lien?

Subrogation is a right to pursue recovery, while a lien is a legal claim or security interest against particular property or funds. Although the terms are often used together, they are not interchangeable.

SubrogationLien
Allows one party to exercise another party's recovery rightsProvides a claim against specified funds or property
May arise through law or contractMay arise through statute, agreement, or another recognized legal basis
Can involve claims against responsible third partiesMay attach to personal injury settlement proceeds
Does not automatically establish a settlement lienMust have an enforceable legal basis

An insurance company may describe its demand as a lien even when its actual legal right is disputed. The name used in a reimbursement letter does not determine whether the demand is enforceable.

Can an Insurance Company Take Money From Your Settlement?

Sometimes, but many New York insurers are prohibited from seeking reimbursement from personal injury settlements.

Under General Obligations Law § 5-335, qualifying settlements are generally presumed not to include compensation for expenses already paid or payable by an insurer. The statute restricts many insurer claims for reimbursement or subrogation against settling parties.

However, § 5-335 expressly preserves exceptions for Medicare, Medicaid, certain additional first-party benefits, and workers' compensation benefits.

Self-funded ERISA plans may also have enforceable rights under federal law despite New York's restrictions. Therefore, determining the type of insurance is essential before deciding whether a reimbursement demand must be paid.

How Does Health Insurance Subrogation Work in New York?

Many ordinary health insurance reimbursement claims are restricted by New York law, but coverage arrangements can change the result.

Fully Insured Health Plans

A conventional health insurance plan that purchases coverage from an insurer is generally subject to applicable state insurance regulations.

General Obligations Law § 5-335 can prevent qualifying reimbursement claims against personal injury settlements. An insurer's reimbursement clause does not automatically override the statute.

Self-Funded ERISA Health Plans

Some employer-sponsored health plans pay benefits directly from employer-funded assets rather than through a conventional insurance policy. These self-funded plans may be governed by the federal Employee Retirement Income Security Act, or ERISA.

In David v. David (2021), the Appellate Division, Second Department, held that New York's anti-subrogation statute was preempted regarding a self-funded ERISA plan with enforceable reimbursement provisions.

The plan documents and actual funding arrangement must be reviewed before accepting or rejecting a reimbursement demand.

Does Medicare Have Subrogation Rights?

Yes. Medicare may recover certain accident-related payments when another insurer or responsible party should have paid those expenses. Under the federal Medicare Secondary Payer framework, Medicare can make conditional payments while responsibility for medical expenses is being determined.

If a personal injury claim later settles, Medicare may seek repayment for qualifying expenses. The process generally involves identifying Medicare payments related to the accident, reviewing disputed charges, and determining the final reimbursement amount.

Medicare's official guidance explains that conditional payments may be recovered when a primary payer's responsibility is established. A demand should be reviewed carefully to identify unrelated treatment, inaccurate charges, and applicable reductions.

Can Medicaid Recover Money From a Personal Injury Settlement?

Yes, Medicaid may have statutory recovery rights when it paid medical expenses connected to an injury caused by another party.

However, Medicaid recovery is subject to federal and state restrictions concerning the portion of a settlement attributable to medical care. This distinction matters because compensation for pain and suffering or lost earnings is not automatically available to satisfy Medicaid reimbursement.

The amount recoverable may require an allocation analysis, particularly when a settlement compensates several categories of damages. New York's Department of Health has issued guidance addressing Medicaid recovery limits following federal court decisions concerning third-party settlements.

How Does Workers' Compensation Subrogation Work?

Under New York Workers' Compensation Law § 29, a compensation carrier may have reimbursement rights when an injured employee recovers damages from a responsible third party.

For example, an employee injured by an outside contractor may receive workers' compensation benefits while pursuing a separate negligence lawsuit. The carrier may have a lien against qualifying third-party recovery proceeds.

However, statutory rules address litigation expenses, reimbursement calculations, and certain benefits that are excluded from liens.

Can Subrogation Affect Future Workers' Compensation Benefits?

Yes. A third-party recovery may also generate a credit affecting future workers' compensation payments.

Under Workers' Compensation Law § 29, certain settlements require the compensation carrier's written consent or an appropriate court order to preserve continuing benefits. These requirements should be addressed before a third-party case is settled.

Does New York No-Fault Insurance Allow Subrogation?

Certain no-fault reimbursement rights exist, but ordinary no-fault benefits are not automatically deducted from an injured person's settlement. Under Insurance Law § 5105, insurers may recover certain first-party benefit payments from other insurers when statutory requirements are satisfied.

These rights generally concern qualifying accidents involving heavy vehicles or vehicles transporting people or property for hire. The process is distinct from demanding repayment directly from an injured claimant.

Additionally, § 5-335 preserves specified claims for additional first-party benefits. Determining whether a claimed reimbursement involves basic no-fault benefits, additional benefits, or a separate insurance obligation is essential.

Are Short-Term Disability Benefits Subject to Subrogation?

Not necessarily. A recent New York appellate decision clarified that certain short-term disability payments are protected by the state's anti-subrogation statute.

In Trombetta v. Eklecco Newco, LLC, decided July 1, 2026, the Appellate Division, Second Department, examined an insurer's attempt to recover short-term disability benefits after a personal injury settlement. The court held that General Obligations Law § 5-335 barred the particular reimbursement claim.

The decision distinguished these short-term disability benefits from workers' compensation benefits preserved under the statute's exception. This illustrates why a reimbursement demand should not be accepted solely because the payer cites a statutory provision.

How Does Subrogation Affect Your Final Settlement Amount?

A valid reimbursement claim may reduce the amount an injured person receives after attorney fees, case expenses, and other enforceable obligations are resolved.

Consider a hypothetical $100,000 settlement:

Settlement itemIllustrative amount
Gross settlement$100,000
Attorney fees and case expenses−$35,000
Valid reimbursement obligation−$10,000
Remaining proceeds$55,000

These numbers are hypothetical. Actual reimbursement rights, deductions, fee arrangements, and settlement calculations vary. Importantly, not every claimed lien is valid, and some obligations may be reduced under applicable law.

Can You Challenge or Negotiate a Subrogation Claim?

Yes. An injured person may dispute a reimbursement demand when the amount is inaccurate or the insurer lacks an enforceable recovery right.

The review should address the following:

  1. Identify the payer: Determine whether the claim involves private insurance, Medicare, Medicaid, workers' compensation, or another plan.
  2. Request supporting documents: Obtain the legal basis, policy provisions, and itemized payment records.
  3. Verify accident-related expenses: Check whether the claimed charges relate to the injury involved in the lawsuit.
  4. Apply relevant protections: Determine whether § 5-335, federal law, or another statute affects enforceability.
  5. Review possible reductions: Evaluate applicable litigation-cost allocations and other authorized adjustments.
  6. Resolve valid claims before distribution: Ensure the settlement is handled consistently with enforceable obligations.

Not every reimbursement demand is negotiable, and applicable laws may restrict available reductions.

Does Subrogation Affect Your Right to Sue?

Subrogation generally does not eliminate an injured person's right to pursue a personal injury lawsuit. Instead, it concerns who may recover particular payments associated with the injury.

For example, a person injured by a negligent property owner may still seek compensation even when an insurer previously paid medical expenses.

However, the insurer's rights may affect settlement negotiations, allocation of proceeds, and the final amount distributed. Depending on the claim, a lawyer may need to address reimbursement questions before completing a settlement agreement.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Do I have to repay my health insurance after a settlement?

Not always. New York restricts many health insurance reimbursement claims, but self-funded ERISA plans and statutory exceptions may have different rights.

Can an insurance company claim my entire settlement?

Not automatically. Any recovery must have a valid legal basis and comply with applicable reimbursement restrictions.

Does subrogation apply to car accident claims?

Yes, potentially. Certain no-fault, health insurance, and other reimbursement rules may apply, depending on the coverage and accident.

Can an attorney help reduce a subrogation claim?

Yes. An attorney can review enforceability, identify incorrect charges, and seek legally available reductions.

Speak With Davidoff Law About Subrogation and Personal Injury Claims

Subrogation can affect how personal injury settlements are handled, but an insurer's demand does not automatically establish a right to repayment. Understanding the insurance coverage, applicable statutes, and potential reimbursement obligations can help protect your financial recovery.

Davidoff Law helps injured people throughout New York City evaluate personal injury claims and insurance-related issues. If you have questions about compensation after an accident, call 718-268-8800 for a free consultation about your legal options.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Personal Injury Lawyer

Ruben Davidoff, founder of Davidoff Law, established his practice in 2012 after moving to Queens in 1988 and beginning his legal career in 1997. Admitted in NY State and the US District Court for the Eastern District of NY, he has extensive experience in personal injury, handling various cases like airline crashes, auto accidents, and slip/trip and fall cases. Mr. Davidoff provides personalized attention, recovering millions for clients through settlements or verdicts, leveraging decades of experience.

Schedule Your Free
Consultation

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name*
Required Field*
Consent

Contact Us

If you or a loved one needs the assistance of our personal injury law attorneys, please feel free to contact in the way that is most convenient to you, whether that is calling us at (718) 268-8800 or completing the contact form below. All fields are required.

chevron-down