How to Get the Most Money from Insurance for a Totaled Car

After a car accident, the insurance company will assess your vehicle's value if it’s considered a totaled car. A total loss means the car’s damage is so severe that repair costs exceed its actual cash value (ACV). Getting the most money from the insurance company is essential to cover the replacement vehicle and other expenses.

Davidoff Law Personal Injury Lawyers helps you maximize your settlement. We understand how car insurance companies operate and can guide you through the process. By providing accurate details and negotiating effectively, we work to get you a fair market value for your totaled vehicle. It’s essential to know how your insurance company calculates the vehicle’s value and what factors can influence your payout.

Our goal is to make sure you receive full compensation for your total loss and any related costs, including repair costs and medical bills.

Understand How Insurance Companies Determine Total Loss Value

When your car is totaled, insurance companies determine its value using the actual cash value (ACV). ACV is based on the fair market value of your car before the accident occurred. Insurance companies look at factors like the car’s age, condition, mileage, and make/model to calculate this amount.

Your insurance company will typically compare your car to similar vehicles in the market to assess its value. This is called "comparative valuation." If your car has any modifications or upgrades, such as a new stereo system or custom wheels, these might also be factored into the valuation.

Your insurance company might offer you a lower payout than you expect. They may undervalue your car based on their estimates or similar vehicles. Knowing how they calculate your car’s value can help you challenge the offer and ensure you receive fair compensation for your totaled car.

Gather Evidence to Support Your Car’s Value

To ensure you get the most money from your insurance company for a totaled car, you should gather evidence that supports the value of your vehicle. The more information you provide, the stronger your claim will be.

Check Your Car’s Market Value

• Fair market value: Use online tools like Kelley Blue Book or Edmunds to check the market value of your car. These websites give you an estimate based on the make, model, year, and condition of your vehicle. This can provide a benchmark for what your car is worth before the accident.
• Comparable vehicles: Look for listings of similar vehicles for sale in your area. These can help demonstrate what others are paying for cars like yours. Make sure to include cars with similar mileage, condition, and features.

This evidence can be useful when negotiating with the insurance company to make sure you get a fair payout for your totaled car.

Document Your Car’s Condition Before the Accident

Before the accident, your car’s condition plays a significant role in determining its value. If your car is in great shape with no major issues, this will work in your favor. Be sure to document any recent maintenance, upgrades, or repairs.

If you had recently replaced parts, such as tires or brakes, keep those receipts as evidence. This helps show the insurance company that your car is well-maintained and could command a higher value.

Also, if your car has any unique features, such as a custom sound system or new paint, make sure to document those as well. Take photos of your car before the accident, especially if it was in good condition. Having this evidence can strengthen your case when negotiating for a higher settlement, as it shows that the car was worth more than the insurance company might initially offer.

Get Your Own Repair Estimate

One of the best ways to support your claim for a totaled car is by getting your own repair estimate. After the accident, the insurance company will assess the cost of repairs, but their estimate may not always reflect the true cost. To make sure you get a fair payout, you can visit a reputable auto repair shop to get an independent repair estimate.

This estimate will give you an idea of how much it would cost to fix the vehicle, which can help you argue that the car is indeed a total loss. If the cost to repair your car is close to or exceeds its actual cash value, this further supports your case. Keep in mind that a reliable, detailed repair estimate can be a strong piece of evidence to present to your insurance company when negotiating your settlement.

Negotiate With the Insurance Adjuster

Negotiating with the insurance adjuster is a key step in getting a fair settlement for your totaled car. The adjuster may offer an initial payout that’s lower than what you deserve. By presenting strong evidence and clearly stating your case, you can improve your chances of getting a higher settlement.

Some important strategies for effective negotiation include the following:

Don’t Accept the First Offer Right Away

When you receive the first settlement offer from the insurance adjuster, do not accept it immediately. It’s common for insurance companies to offer a low initial amount. This is often less than what you are truly entitled to for your totaled car. Accepting this offer too quickly could result in a lower payout.

Instead, take the time to review the offer carefully. Compare it to the evidence you’ve gathered, such as your car’s market value, repair estimates, and maintenance records. If the offer doesn’t cover these expenses, be ready to negotiate for more.

You can also consult with a car accident lawyer who can help you evaluate the offer and determine if it’s fair. A lawyer can also handle negotiations with the insurance adjuster, ensuring you don’t miss out on the full compensation you deserve for your car’s value.

Present Your Evidence

When negotiating with the insurance adjuster, presenting clear and organized evidence is crucial. This helps strengthen your case and shows the insurance company that you’re serious about getting fair compensation for your totaled car.

Start by showing the evidence of your car’s value before the accident. This includes the market value, repair estimates, and maintenance records. Present photos of your car’s condition before the accident and evidence of any upgrades or improvements you made.

If you have receipts for repairs or modifications, include those too. Having all these documents ready will show the adjuster that your car is worth more than what they might initially offer. The more evidence you provide, the harder it will be for the insurance company to undervalue your claim.

Be prepared to explain each piece of evidence and how it supports your case for a higher settlement.

Demand a Line-Item Breakdown of the Valuation

When the insurance adjuster provides a settlement offer, ask for an explanation of how they arrived at the valuation. This is important because it gives you insight into how they calculated the total loss value of your car and whether it aligns with the actual cash value (ACV).

Request information about the specific factors used, such as the car’s make, model, year, mileage, and condition before the accident. Insurance companies sometimes use pricing tools like Kelley Blue Book or Edmunds to determine the car’s value. If these tools were used, ask for the exact figures to discover how they compare to your vehicle’s actual worth.

If you feel the valuation is unfair or undervalued, present your own evidence to challenge it. This could include the repair estimates, photos, or any comparable vehicle listings that show a higher value. A detailed breakdown can help you identify discrepancies and make a stronger case.

Ask for a Higher Settlement

If the insurance company’s initial offer doesn’t meet your expectations, don’t be afraid to ask for a higher settlement. Insurance adjusters often offer a low amount at first, hoping you’ll accept it without question. You have every right to request more, especially if the first offer doesn’t fully cover the actual value of your totaled car.

Present the evidence you’ve gathered, such as the car’s market value, repair estimates, and photos showing its pre-accident condition. These documents can help justify why you believe the offer is too low. Be clear and assertive about why you’re asking for a higher payout. Make sure the offer reflects not just the value of your car but also any associated expenses, like towing fees or storage costs.

If the insurance adjuster is unwilling to offer a fair settlement, you may want to consult a lawyer to help negotiate a better deal.

Consider Additional Compensation Options

When dealing with your totaled car, you must explore all possible compensation options. In addition to the settlement offer for the car’s value, there may be other expenses or damages you can recover. Understanding these options can help you get the most from your insurance claim.

A few of these additional options are:

Sales Tax and Registration Fees

When receiving a settlement for your totaled car, you might be entitled to compensation for sales tax and registration fees. These fees are often overlooked but are part of the overall costs of replacing your vehicle.

• Sales tax: If you use the settlement money to buy a new car, the insurance company may include sales tax as part of the payout. This ensures you have enough to cover the full cost of purchasing a replacement vehicle.
• Registration fees: Similarly, if you’re purchasing a new car, you’ll need to pay for registration. In some cases, the insurance company may cover these costs as well, reducing your out-of-pocket expenses.

Be sure to ask the insurance company about these costs. If they aren’t included in the initial settlement, you can negotiate for them to be added. Including sales tax and registration fees ensures you’re fully compensated for your total loss.

Gap Insurance (If You Have a Loan or Lease)

If you have a loan or lease on your vehicle, gap insurance can be a valuable option. Gap insurance covers the difference between what you owe on the car and its ACV. Without gap insurance, if your car is totaled, your regular insurance company might only pay you the ACV, which may not cover the full amount you still owe on the car.

For example, if your car’s value has depreciated considerably since you purchased it, you may owe more than it's worth. In this case, gap insurance can fill in the "gap" and cover the remaining balance, so you don’t have to pay out of pocket.

If you have gap insurance, be sure to inform your insurance company so they can include it in your settlement. This extra coverage can help prevent financial hardship after a total loss.

Diminished Value Claim (If the Car Isn’t Totaled)

If your car is not completely totaled but has still suffered major damage, you might be able to file a diminished value claim. This type of claim is for the loss in value your vehicle experiences after being in an accident. Even if the car is repaired, it may still be worth less than it was before the accident.

Insurance companies often overlook the diminished value of a car, focusing only on repair costs. However, if your car’s resale value has decreased due to the accident, you have the right to seek compensation for that lost value.

To pursue a diminished value claim, you’ll need to provide proof of your car’s market value before and after the accident. This could include car appraisal reports or listings for comparable vehicles. A car accident lawyer can help you gather the evidence and negotiate for a fair settlement.

Explore Alternative Settlement Options

In addition to negotiating with your own insurance company, there may be alternative settlement options that could help you recover more for your totaled car. Exploring these options could lead to a higher payout or a more favorable resolution to your case.

Keeping the Salvage Title

In some cases, you may want to keep the damaged car after it’s been declared a total loss. If you still need the car or want to repair it yourself, you can request a salvage title from your insurance company. This allows you to keep the car while receiving compensation for its value.

However, the insurance company will usually reduce the payout for the vehicle's value, reflecting its status as a salvage vehicle. If you’re considering keeping your car, you must understand the potential financial impact. You’ll also need to handle repairs and make sure the vehicle is safe to drive. Additionally, you may face challenges if you decide to sell or insure the car in the future.

Before accepting a salvage title, weigh the pros and cons. Consult with a car accident lawyer to ensure you make the best decision for your situation.

Filing a Claim Against the At-Fault Driver’s Insurance

If the accident was caused by another driver, you may be able to file a claim against their insurance company. This is especially useful if their policy provides higher coverage than your own. If the other driver is at fault, their insurance should cover the damage to your car, medical expenses, and any other costs related to the accident.

In order to file a claim against the at-fault driver’s insurance, you will need to gather evidence that clearly shows they are responsible for the crash. This includes photos of the accident scene, witness statements, and the police report. If the other driver is uninsured or underinsured, you may have to rely on your insurance policy or file a lawsuit.

Working with a personal injury lawyer can help ensure that you get the compensation you deserve, especially if there are complications with the other driver’s insurance.

What to Do If Insurance Refuses to Pay Fairly

If your insurance company refuses to offer a fair payout for your totaled car, you have options to challenge their decision. First, review the details of your policy to confirm the coverage limits and your rights. If the offer seems too low or the insurance company undervalues your car, you can negotiate for a higher settlement.

It’s important to gather all supporting evidence, such as the car’s market value, repair estimates, and any other documentation that shows the true value of your vehicle. If you cannot reach a fair settlement with your insurance company, consider filing a formal complaint with the state’s insurance department or taking legal action.

Consulting with a car accident lawyer can be crucial if the insurance company refuses to pay fairly. A lawyer can help you understand your options and guide you through the process of pursuing the compensation you deserve.

FAQs

Contact Our Manhattan Car Accident Lawyer for a Free Consultation

If your car has been totaled in an auto accident, you deserve fair compensation. Davidoff Law Personal Injury Lawyers can help you secure the best cash settlement possible for your total loss auto claims. Our experienced team works with you to ensure the insurance company offers a fair payout based on your vehicle's actual cash value.

We also help with personal injury claims, making sure that medical bills, lost wages, and other damages are fully covered. Whether dealing with your own insurance company or the at-fault party’s insurer, our team is here to guide you through the entire process.

If you're unsure about the next steps or feel your settlement is too low, we offer a free consultation to review your case. Don’t settle for less than you deserve — contact us today to schedule your free case review.